2009 duo-biopicRating: 13/20 (Jen: 16/20; Becky: 18/20; Tom: 8/20)
Plot: An extremely whiny wannabe writer named Julie moves to Queens with her supportive and loving husband. She hates her friends and her job and doesn't understand why nobody else thinks she's the most important person on the planet. Since all egomaniacal whiny wannabe writers wind up starting blogs, she decides to start her own, a three hundred and sixty-five day adventure in which she'll cook all five hundred and some recipes in the Julia Child cookbook. Her irritating story is juxtaposed with Julia Child's life with her own supportive and loving husband and her developing interest in cooking. The two meet, and the bitter elderly Julia Child (***spoiler alert***) defeats Julie in an epic fight with utensils and rolling pins and then forces her husband to watch as she debones her and devours her lifeless carcass while giggling madly through blood-stained false teeth.
I would have really liked this if it was just called Julia. Meryl Streep is great in her portrayal of the quirky and fascinating Childs. There's some humorous banter between her and her husband, and there are also some very touching moments as well. When the movie focused on Julia Childs, this was actually good. Unfortunately, there's a Julie in the story, too. She wrote the blog, she turned the blog into the book, and the book and blog gave her the easy fame she longed for. If the character in the movie is anything like the real person, as I suspect is the case, then the real person is irritating, pretentious, and hopelessly self-centered. The most revealing part of her story is when she finds out that Julia Childs hates her. It was easy to see why. Almost everything she says is irritating, and every minute detail of her life is blown up into a major drama. As my faithful readers know, I'm not generally a hateful fellow, but I genuinely hope that people start randomly attacking her with food at all her future speaking engagements. Julie is played by the mousy Amy Adams, sort of a Meg Ryan lite. And it's hard to imagine an actress lighter and fluffier than Meg Ryan. This is the type of role that will likely cause me to never give her a fair chance in another movie. Actually, her annoying character in this might cause me to completely avoid any future Amy Adams movies unless Crispin Glover or Vincent Price happens to be in them as well. So, to sum it all up: Meryl Streep is great. Somebody needs to slap around Julie Powell. Oh, one final note. If you watch this hoping to see a Julia Child sex scene, expect to be disappointed. Close counts only in horseshoes and hand grenades and not in Julia Child sex scenes.
5 comments:
Funny review. I like Adams (cool name) in "Enchanted". You?
'Enchanted'? The only way I'm watching that is if they show it on a plane or at my school.
I REALLY did not want to watch this(I don't like Streep), but since it will probably get Oscar noms and they didn't have anything else at Redbox, I took a chance.
Two thoughts: I really liked the film, and I totally disagree with your Amy Adams/ Julie Powell rant. Adams does a very good job in this showing a wide range of emotions in a well-rounded character. She is sweet, searching, motivated, narcissistic, whiny, repentent, and back to kind. She is refreshingly human and flawed. At least in the movie, her charater's motivations are honest. She starts out finding a passion and doing something with it. In the film her intent is not to get fame and fortune by using Child. She doesn't go in thinking about book or movie deals. She does what she does in honor of Child (Adams is constantly respectful and in awe of her hero), and her need to do something that she loves. The real Julie Powell might be a user, but in the movie I respect her character. I think you might be suffering from blog-envy.
This movie is very funny, well constructed, and has a great concept. Streep is very good (although Child is such an unusual personality that the role always feels close to being a parody), as are both saintly husbands. A true love of food, and the art of cooking are brilliantly conveyed. "Julie & Julia" is fun, touching, educational, and much better than expected. A 16.
It's the narcissism that makes it obvious that she's looking for fame the whole time. She's a whiny malcontent. She wants so much to be a writer and found an easy way to fame and fortune. I can't believe you liked the character. You may be a movie aficionado, but your "annoying person" IQ must be very very low.
Very funny?
"Refreshingly human" is an oxymoron, by the way. Ask the buffalo.
This just got catty!
Post a Comment