1937 best picture
Rating: 16/20
Plot: A 19th Century French writer makes his living trolling society. When an innocent man is court-martialed for being a spy and sent to Devil's Island--a historically not-very-nice place--his wife comes to Zola to look for help. Zola risks his own freedom by trying to uncover the truth.
There are things that are dated about this, but it doesn't take away any of its impact. The titular character is nice and meaty, the kind screenwriters create just so that some actor can tackle the role and win an Oscar. Paul Muni's that actor, and his performance is a powerful one. He seems to gain wisdom as he ages, and gets all kinds of juicy lines to make Acting with that capital A happen. His big courtroom monologue should be more famous than it is. Muni shows some versatility since there's nothing gangsta about Zola at all, and he seems to get better as the movie goes on. I also really liked the performance of Joseph Schildkraut as the wrongly-accused Dreyfus; he nails one of his final scenes as he emerges from a prison cell as an older Dreyfus, and he does it without any words at all. Beautiful stuff. Dieterle's direction is simple and probably more effective for it. There are some lighting choices and slow zoom-outs that reminded me of moves from the silent era. Other than that, there's not much style to speak of which only helps you focus more on the complexities of the story. Like Argo, the history's a little hugger-muggered, but it's not as sneaky as Affleck's storytelling. There's even a title card that tells you it's not 100% historical at the beginning of the movie. This is a movie that is never really gripping, but it's consistently interesting, and the performances make it a 1930's classic that more people should probably know about.
And I really need to throw "muckraking" into conversation more.
Recommended by Cory.
3 comments:
I was unsure how you would feel about this since it is a little dated and stagey. I think you're exactly right about Muni. He does a terrific job getting his righteous on, and the story is very moving. I'm very happy you liked it and thanks for giving it a chance. An 18 from me. My replacement would be "Into the Arms of Strangers", another movie about regretable history.
I'm going to assume that is the documentary and not the 2007 mystery thriller...
You assume correctly. Sorry, I forgot there was another movie with the same name. The one I am recommending also includes "The Kindertransport", which sort of gives the plot away.
Post a Comment